This is a book written by a Spurs fan - it is an
account of Spurs last season under Christian Gross, George Graham and Alan
Sugar. Whilst it is in no
way Watford-related, the author has thrown up a
number of issues that impact
on how the "average" football fan watches the game
we love and, at times,
hate. This is a book that you will love and hate in
equal measure.
Key issues that Mark touches on are how the
direction of the club is
influenced by the Chairman's desire for success, the
development or
abdication of a club's "DNA", football on the altar
of commercialism and the
role the manager performs for the club and fans.
Firstly, let's look at what
Mark writes about the Hornets.
There are two references to Watford - one recounts
the result of the FA Cup
3rd round game which the Hornets lost 5-2 and the
other is a less than
flattering reference to Tim Sherwood. The Spurs win
in the cup is regarded
as a formality - missing out on the fact that
Watford gifted the Lillywhites
a goal or two and the run-around Gifton Noel
Williams gave Sol Campbell. The
reference to Tim Sherwood concerns his less than
sporting attitude on the
pitch - which the author argues may be acceptable at
his previous clubs (i.e. Watford, Norwich and Blackburn) but not at Spurs.
Had to laugh at that, as
Sherwood at Watford was like Bambi on acid, all
action, no direction and
very little bite. Though from what little I can
remember of Tim at the Vic,
he was always had the potential to be a petulant
primadonna.
Turning to the role of Chairman of the club, Mark
discusses at length the
negative impact of Alan Sugar - whose emphasis on
running a profitable
business means that Spurs have missed out on a
number of players who could
have joined the club. Sugar's short-term focus
on not purchasing "Carlos Kickaballs" has impacted
on long-term success
at White Hart Lane. Sugar can't just live on the
legacy of saving the club,
he also needs to build it up to become a success.
By not spending to build a competitive team, Spurs
are not the mythically
glorious and successful team that their fans crave
to see as a consequence of Sugar's focus on profit and loss. As Sugar is not
keen to purchase
expensive players, the attraction of Manchester
United, Arsenal and Chelsea
have soared in comparison - to both players and
armchair supporters. For a
Spurs fan to admit that they are no longer London's
glamour club is a bitter
pill to swallow. Mark's book deals with this at
length and there is no love
lost between himself and the Chairman.
What lies at the heart of a club? Mark proposes that
each team has its own
unique identity, its "DNA", what makes the club
and its fans tick. Spurs
demand attractive football, with emphasis on skill
and ability rather than
grinding out results, West Ham on the other hand,
focus on bringing kids
through their Academy. When a club ignores its
history of purchasing stars
or developing stars then it is likely that the team
will come off the rails.
For instance Harry Redknapp's flirtation with a
string of temperamental
overseas stars was catastrophic for the Hammers,
until he rebuilt using Rio
Ferdinand, Frank Lampard junior, Steve Potts and
other home grown players as
the spine of the team.
I think that the DNA concept is worth considering.
Watford have had a great
youth team and community tradition - which Graham
Taylor developed first he
was at the Vic, but subsequent Hornets managers lost
their way. It is
amazing that the return of GT has breathed new life
back into both. For most
fans to see homegrown talent come through really is
a source of great
pride. Moreover, to get a signed football for a
friend in hospital or for a
retirement party within a couple of days, further
adds to the relationship
between the club and the fans.
However Mark seems to think that Spurs' DNA is one of
success and glory - I
don't think so. If that was the case Huddersfield,
Wolves, Birmingham,
Everton, Liverpool etc. would be challenging for the
title year in year out.
Why did Newcastle and Sunderland struggle for so
many years? Why have
Blackburn fallen away in the last couple of seasons?
Probably because they
haven't taken care of the grass roots. Success and
consequently glory must
be earnt - it does not happen overnight - or
generation to generation, it is
not a virtue inherited from previous teams, or for
example, Liverpool would
still be the English super-team and not Manchester
United.
Having enjoyed the two promotions that Watford has
had the last couple of
seasons and our winning trip to the twin towers, I
believe that success is
earnt through hard work, talent and inspirational
management. The turnaround
that GT has engineered at Watford is remarkable and
is largely due to his
outstanding management skills and powers of
motivation. A team of unknown
players will by the end of the season contain a
number of players the envy
of other teams.
The impact of the Premiership on football in England
and abroad has been
remarkable. Money, glamour and hype have warped
directors, players and fans
expectations of the game. We have seen this at
Watford with the present
board shenanigans and the rip-off increase in ticket
prices and yet another
new kit. Whilst Watford players don't demand 24,000
per week as did David
Ginola, we still have to compete in the same league
as him. We don't want to
see the club in turmoil as it is at Leicester
because the Board are split
between two factions - those favouring the football
team and those the
commercial interests of the club.
Sky TV has had a profound influence on when and
where football matches are
played. Cup semi finals that are staggered, league
games rearranged for TV
audiences, etc. Watford's game at Leicester was
rearranged from a Saturday
to a Bank Holiday Monday night - absolutely crazy.
However, again let's make
it clear, Watford are in the Premier League and will
suffer accordingly the
whims of TV schedulers.
As for George Graham? Would you swap him for Graham
Taylor? No, me neither.
Dour football, 1-0 wins and high tempo football
versus great motivation,
organisation and at times magic, there is no
comparison or even contest.
Can't wait till Boxing Day when the Horns visit
White Hart Lane.
As for "What's The Story?" itself, it is a good and
thought-provoking read. It
is definitely a book you should read if you are
concerned about our great
game. It gives an insight into what a fan from
another team thinks. At
times he's not too far removed from us Hornets. There are
other times you might think
that he's on another planet, expecting glory
and success as a
rightful reward for years of loyal supporting.
However, I suppose that is a
sign of a good book that gets you wound up by his
lack of realism.
Peter Wilson